Statistical Anomalies in Reports Originating in the EU


Over the last several months a number of reports have been
published on the impact of file sharing of popular music on Europe's
macro economy.

The purpose of this paper is to identify a number of arguments that have been
made that are provably false or present data that is contrary to other
so-called factual data that is diametrically opposed the data in these reports.

The question is what the rationale might be for publishing reports that can be
so easily disproven. While we can only surmise what is behind this, we have a
very deep concern with the concept of publishing and promoting information that
could possibly be treated as fact and which could then be used to argue changes
in legislation governing various rights that ordinary citizens may have, particularly
with respect to their ability to have an ongoing internet connection.

The fundamental problem with reports of this kind is that they create an
environment where logical arguments are made based on false hypotheses. And as
any good student of logic understands, if you start with a false hypothesis it
is impossible to reach a provably true conclusion.

The pursuit of changes to legislation based on false hypotheses, if successful,
would almost certainly lead to random unforseeable events and trends taking
place that are totally contrary to the philosophical development of the human
race and would overturn hundreds of years of enlightenment thinking.

For this reason we believe that the analysis of these recent reports should be
carefully considered by readers interested in the legal structures that govern
both content and communications as they pertain to citizens.


Unfortunately, the details of our response to these various reports
now contain many pages [188] of dry, boring statistical data and there is unfortunately
no real way to proffer a rebuttal suitable to present in a Blog format that


a)       Be
of interest to the great majority of Perceptric readers.

b)       Be
presented in a continuous format suitable for cross-referencing and

c)       Be
taken seriously by anyone in either Government or Ministerial advisory roles.


Therefore  over the
next few days, highlights (the more interesting bits) of our research will be published
as a series of articles here on Perceptric, and when complete, the entire
report  will be tendered (in a more
formal fashion) for consideration and comment by academics amongst the global


Report Number 1.


a Digital Economy : The Importance of Saving Jobs in the EU’s Creative


The study focuses on three questions :


1) What is the contribution of the creative
industries to the European economy in terms of GDP and jobs ?

2) What are the consequences of piracy on retail
revenue and jobs ?

3) If current policies do not change in the EU, what
will these losses be by 2015 ?

We urge readers to read this report in its entirety, so that
the highlights of our research in answer to many of these reports findings will
have relevance.

Comments are closed.